We already analyzed the numerous benefits of E-Learning in our previous article. Now, it’s time to cover the opposite side of the coin. E-Learning has some significant drawbacks, and these problems often get pushed aside in online discussions. After all, who would want to put the brakes on educational innovation?
Looking at the industry as a whole also reveals plenty of enthusiasm, with the statistics of the E-Learning industry in 2022 showing massive growth. However, educators worldwide still recognize some major issues plaguing the industry. Let’s have a closer look at these problems.
These are the disadvantages of E-Learning:
Disadvantages of E-Learning
1. Online student feedback is limited
In traditional classrooms, teachers can give students immediate face-to-face feedback. Students who are experiencing problems in the curriculum can resolve them quickly and directly either during the lecture or during dedicated office hours. Personalized feedback has a positive impact on students, as it makes learning processes easier, richer, and more significant, all the while raising the motivation levels of the students.
E-Learning, on the other hand, still tends to struggle with student feedback. Students completing regular assessments become dissatisfied when they experience a lack of personalized feedback. The traditional methods of providing student feedback don’t always work in an E-Learning environment, and because of this, online education providers are forced to look towards alternative methods for providing feedback. Providing student feedback in an online setting is still a relatively unresearched topic area, and it might take a while for any specific strategies to become fully research-based and proven to be effective.
Solution: Researchers have demonstrated successful examples of peer feedback systems in online learning, which could be a potential solution to the problem of limited student feedback in e-learning. Additionally, this disadvantage of E-Learning is sometimes solved through video chats with professors, which function similarly to the professor’s office hours during on-campus training.
2. E-Learning can cause social Isolation
The E-Learning methods currently practiced in education tend to make participating students engage in solitary contemplation without interaction. As a result, many students and teachers who inevitably spend much of their time online can start experiencing signs of social isolation due to the lack of human communication in their lives. Social isolation and lack of communication often lead to several mental health issues, such as heightened stress, anxiety, and negative thoughts.
Solution: Some of the ways to combat loneliness and social isolation in online learning could be:
- Promoting increased interaction between online students.
- Utilizing blended learning environments.
- Monitoring the students for signs of social isolation.
3. E-Learning requires strong self-motivation and time management skills
Lack of self-motivation among students continues to be one of the primary reasons why students fail to complete online courses. In traditional classrooms, there are numerous factors that constantly push students toward their learning goals. Face-to-face communication with professors, peer-to-peer activities, and strict schedules all help keep the students from falling off track during their studies.
In the setting of an online learning environment, however, there are fewer external factors that push the students to perform well. In many cases, the students are left to fend for themselves during their learning activities, without anyone constantly urging them towards their learning goals. Students taking E-Learning courses will find that they are often required to learn difficult materials in a comfortable home setting without any of the added pressure normally associated with traditional colleges. As a result, keeping up with regular deadlines during online studies can become difficult for those students who lack strong self-motivation and time management skills.
Solution: Building strong self-motivation and disciplinary skills is key to succeeding in an online learning environment. Additionally, face-to-face communication with professors can be substituted with online communication, and peer-to-peer activities should be promoted between online students similarly as it would be in traditional classrooms.
4. Lack of communicational skill development in online students
E-Learning methods are proven to be highly effective at improving the academic knowledge of students. However, developing the communicational skills of the students is an area often neglected during online lessons. Due to the lack of face-to-face communication between peers, students, and teachers in an online setting, the students might find that they are unable to work effectively in a team setting. Neglecting the communicational skills of the students will inevitably lead to many graduates who excel in theoretical knowledge, but who fail to pass their knowledge on to others.
Solution: Peer-to-peer group activities and online lectures which require communication must be used even in an online learning environment. In doing so, we can ensure that E-Learning does not fail to teach students the communication skills necessary to succeed in real working environments.
5. Cheating prevention during online assessments is complicated
Unfortunately, one of the biggest disadvantages of E-Learning continues to be cheating through various methods. Compared to on-campus students, online students can cheat on assessments more easily as they take assessments in their own environment and while using their personal computers. The students cannot be directly observed during assessments without a video feed, making cheat detection during online assessments more complicated than for traditional testing procedures. Additionally, without a proper identity verification system in place, students taking online assessments might be able to let a third party take the assessment instead of themselves, resulting in a wholly fraudulent test result.
Solution: To protect the authenticity of online education, anti-cheating measures must be put in place by any online education institution. The most popular anti-cheating tools currently used in E-Learning are online proctoring systems such as Examity, which use various anti-cheating measures, including automated ID verification and machine learning to detect fraudulent test-takers.
6. Online instructors tend to focus on theory rather than practice
Although this drawback of E-Learning is starting to be addressed and fixed by some of the more innovative online learning platforms, the problem has yet to disappear completely. The problem is that many E-Learning training providers focus largely (in many cases entirely) on developing theoretical knowledge rather than practical skills. The reason for this is evident – theoretical lectures are considerably easier to implement in an online learning environment than practical lectures. After all, without face-to-face communication and physical classrooms to use as a workshop, implementing practical projects in an online course requires significantly more prior planning than theoretical training.
Solution: Implementing hands-on student projects in conjunction with 1:1 mentorship is some of the most effective ways of developing practical skills in online students. There are several successful practice-based online courses on platforms such as Udacity and Springboard.
7. E-Learning lacks face-to-face communication
The lack of face-to-face communication ties together with many previously mentioned disadvantages of online learning. A lack of face-to-face communication with the instructor inhibits student feedback, causes social isolation, and could cause students to feel a lack of pressure. A lack of pressure is a disadvantage because it causes students to abandon their studies more easily. Constant nudging by professors may be undesirable for many, but it’s an effective method for improving student retention.
Solution: In E-Learning, face-to-face communication must be substituted with another method of communication. For example, video chats, discussion boards, and chatrooms could help with the adverse effects of a lack of face-to-face contact during online learning.
8. E-Learning is limited to certain disciplines
All educational disciplines are not created equal, and not all study fields can be effectively pursued via E-Learning – for now, at least. E-Learning tends to be more suitable for social science and humanities rather than scientific fields such as medical science and engineering, which require a certain degree of hands-on practical experience. No amount of online lectures can substitute an autopsy for medical students or real-life industrial training for a budding engineer. While this could change in the future, we are not yet at a point where we can teach all professions solely through E-Learning.
Solution: For some disciplines, such as medical education, blended learning could be an excellent alternative to fully online learning. In the case of nursing students, research showed that blended learning courses achieved similar post-test results as traditional course formats while increasing the satisfaction ratings of the participating students significantly.
9. Online learning is inaccessible to the computer illiterate population
96% of Americans own mobile devices, and around 73% own a personal computer. Therefore, it would be easy to argue that online education is accessible to most people. However, these statistics don’t paint the whole picture. Despite the booming growth in technological capabilities, computer literacy rates are still far from perfect. The OECD average percentage of computer-illiterate people hovers around 25%, meaning that a quarter of the population will have considerable trouble accessing E-Learning as an educational method. And these are OECD countries we are talking about, considered developed countries with high-income economies.
In other parts of the world, the situation is often direr. In India, for example, despite the country being one of the major players in the world of E-Learning, there is still a large gap in computer literacy in the population. As long as such gaps in society exist, online education will not be able to reach all citizens. Therefore, we must look at online learning as a supplement rather than a replacement for traditional education.
Solution: Finding a solution to the complex problem of raising computer literacy is no easy task. However, initiatives such as Digital India show promise in improving the computer literacy rates amongst the population.
10. Lack of accreditation & quality assurance in online education
If E-Learning is to be considered as effective and authentic as traditional learning, it must be ensured that all online schools are qualified and accredited. Unfortunately, at the current point in time, there are still a vast number of online learning platforms which are unaccredited and where all the materials are quality checked by no one besides the instructors themselves. As such, poor quality assurance and a lack of accredited online learning providers continue to weaken the legitimacy of online education.
Solution: There are numerous considerations for the quality assurance of E-Learning, and they must be followed to ensure the authenticity of E-Learning. Additionally, accreditation management systems such as Creatrix provide a centralized solution for the accreditation process.